¡¡¡¡Õª Òª£º¡¡Ä¿µÄ£º¶Ô±ÈÑо¿»ðÕëÅäºÏƽºâÕëºÍ³£¹æÕë´ÌÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹Ç¹Ø½ÚÑ×£¨KOA£©µÄÁÙ´²ÁÆÐ§¡£·½·¨£ºÑ¡È¡2016Äê6ÔÂÖÁ2017Äê8ÔÂÆÚ¼äÔÚ¹ãÖÝÖÐÒ½Ò©´óѧµÚÈý¸½ÊôÒ½Ôº½ÓÊÜÖÎÁƵÄKOA»¼Õß67Àý£¬·Ö³Éµ¥Ò»×飨34Àý£©ºÍ¸´ºÏ×飨33Àý£©¡£µ¥Ò»×é½ÓÊܳ£¹æºÁÕëÖÎÁÆ£¬¶ø¸´ºÏ×é½ÓÊÜ»ðÕëÅäºÏƽºâÕëÖÎÁÆ¡£ÌÛÍ´ÊÓ¾õÄ£ÄâÆÀ·Ö£¨VAS£©¡¢¹Ç¹Ø½ÚÖ¸ÊýÁ¿±í£¨WOMAC£©ºÍÁÙ´²×ÛºÏÁÆÐ§ÆÀ¹À×÷Ϊ¼ìÑéÕë¾ÄÁÆÐ§µÄÖ¸±ê¡£²ÉÓÃt¼ìÑéºÍχ2¼ìÑéÀ´±È½ÏÖÎÁÆÇ°ºóºÍ2ÖÖÖÎÁÆ·½·¨Ö®¼äµÄÁÆÐ§²î±ð¡£½á¹û£º2×黼ÕßÄêÁä¡¢ÐԱ𹹳ɡ¢²¡³Ì¡¢ÖÎÁÆÇ°VASºÍWOMACÆÀ·Ö²îÒì¾ùÎÞͳ¼ÆÑ§ÒâÒ壨P>0.05£©¡£³£¹æºÁÕëÖÎÁƺ͸´ºÏÕë¾ÄÁÆ·¨¾ùÓÐЧµØ½µµÍÁËVASºÍWOMACÆÀ·Ö£¨P<0.05£©£¬±íÃ÷2ÖÖÖÎÁÆ·½·¨¾ùÄÜÓÐЧµØ»º½âKOA»¼ÕߵIJ¡Çé¡£Óëµ¥Ò»ºÁÕëÁÆ·¨Ïà±È£¬¸´ºÏÕë¾ÄÁÆ·¨ÔÚ»º½â»¼ÕßÌÛÍ´¡¢¹Ç¹Ø½Ú½©Ö±ºÍ»î¶¯Õϰ·½Ãæ¸üÏÔ×Å£¨P<0.05£©¡£´ËÍ⣬¾¡¹Ü2ÖÖÖÎÁÆ·½·¨ÔÚKOAÖÎÁƵÄ×ÜÓÐЧÂÊÏàËÆ£¨P>0.05£©£¬µ«¸´ºÏÕë¾Ä·¨ÔÚÖÎÓúÂʺÍÓúÏÔÂÊÉϵÄÁÙ´²ÁÆÐ§Ã÷ÏÔ¸ßÓÚµ¥Ò»ºÁÕë·¨£¨P<0.05£©¡£½áÂÛ£º»ðÕëÅäºÏƽºâÕëµÄ¸´ºÏÕë¾Ä·¨ÔÚÖÎÁÆKOAµÄÁÙ´²Ð§¹ûÉÏÓÅÓÚ³£¹æÕë´Ì·½·¨¡£
¡¡¡¡¹Ø¼ü´Ê£º¡¡¹Ç¹Ø½ÚÑ×,Ï¥; ºÁÕëÁÆ·¨; »ðÕëÁÆ·¨; ƽºâÕëÁÆ·¨;
¡¡¡¡Abstract£º¡¡Objective: To compare the clinical efficacy of fire needle combined with balance needle versus the conventional needle in the treatment of knee osteoarthritis. Methods: A retrospective study was made of totally 67 patients with knee osteoarthritis received treated from June 2016 to August 2017 in the Orthopedics and Traumatology Department of the Third Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou University of Traditional Chinese Medicine. They were randomly classified into single acupuncture group(34 patients) and compound acupuncture group(33 patients). The single acupuncture group received the conventional filiform needle therapy, while the compound acupuncture group received fire needle combined with balanced needle therapy. VAS, WOMAC, and the comprehensive clinical efficacy evaluation were used as indicators to test the effectiveness of two therapeutic methods. t-test and χ2-test were used to compare the differences in curative effect between pre-treatment and post-treatment, as well as those the inter-group treatment efficiency. Results: Similarities were observed in age, sex, disease duration, VAS and WOMAC score between the groups before treatment(P>0.05). Conventional filiform needle therapy and combined needle therapy effectively reduced VAS and WOMAC scores of patients with knee osteoarthritis, indicating that both methods effectively alleviated the condition of knee osteoarthritis patients(P<0.05). Compared with single filiform needle therapy, combined needle therapy was more effective in relieving pain, stiffness of bone and joint, and disturbance of movement(P<0.05). Besides, although the overall efficacy of the two methods were similar(P>0.05), the curative effect of combined-needle therapy on knee osteoarthritis was significantly higher than that of single needle method(P<0.05). Conclusion: The clinical effectiveness of fire needle combined with balanced needle was better than that of conventional needling method in the treatment of knee osteoarthritis.
¡¡¡¡Keyword£º¡¡osteoarthritis,knee; milli-needle therapy; fire needle therapy; balanced needle therapy;
¡¡¡¡Ï¥¹Ç¹Ø½ÚÑ×£¨knee osteoarthritis,KOA£©ÊÇÒ»ÖÖÁÙ´²Éϳ£¼ûµÄÍË»¯ÐԹؽڼ²²¡[1]¡£ÕâÖÖÂýÐÔ¼²²¡»¼ÕßÊýÄ¿Ëæ×ÅÄêÁäµÄÔö¼Ó¶øÖðÄêÉý¸ß[2]¡£Ëæ×ÅÎÒ¹úÈË¿ÚÀÏÁ仯£¬KOAÒѳÉΪÉç»á¹Ø×¢µÄ½¹µãÖ®Ò»¡£KOA»¼Õß²»½öÐж¯ÉÏÊܵ½ÏÞÖÆ£¬¶øÇÒÈç²»Äܵõ½¼°Ê±ÓÐЧµÄÖÎÁÆ£¬53%µÄ»¼ÕßÓпÉÄÜ×îºóÎÞ·¨Ðж¯¶øµ¼Ö²зϣ¬ÕâÎÞÒɽµµÍÁË»¼ÕßµÄÈÕ³£Éú»îÐÐΪÄÜÁ¦¡¢¼ÓÖØÁ˼ÒÍ¥ºÍÉç»á¸ºµ£[3,4]¡£¾¡¹ÜһЩÎ÷Ò½Ò©ÎÈç·ÇçÞÌ忹Ñ×Ò©£©ÄÜÓÐЧµØ»º½â»¼ÕßµÄÌÛÍ´£¬µ«Æä³¦µÀ²»Á¼·´Ó¦Ã÷ÏÔ£¬Òò´Ë×÷ÓÃÓÐÏÞ¡£Í¬Ê±£¬ÓÉÓÚKOAµÄ²¡ÒòÉв»Çå³þ£¬Î÷Ò½ÔÚÖÎÁÆKOAÉϵÄÑо¿½øÕ¹ÓÐÏÞ[5]¡£
¡¡¡¡´«Í³Õë¾ÄÖÎÁÆKOAÓÐ×ÅÓÆ¾ÃµÄÁÙ´²ÀúÊ·¡£´«Í³Õë¾ÄÔÚÏû³ý»¼ÕßÏ¥¹Ø½ÚÖ×ÕÍ£¬¸ÄÉÆ»î¶¯¹¦ÄÜ£¬Ìá¸ßÉú»îÖÊÁ¿¶¼ÓÐ×ÅÏÔ×ŵÄЧ¹û£¬¶øÇÒÎÞÃ÷ÏԵIJ»Á¼·´Ó¦£¬¹ÊÖµµÃÔÚÁÙ´²ÉÏÍÆ¹ãºÍÉîÈëÑо¿[6]¡£µ«KOAÊÇÒ»ÖÖ¸´ÔÓµÄÂýÐÔ¼²²¡£¬Æä²¡Òò¸´ÔÓ£¬²¡³Ì³¤£¬ÖÎÓúÂʵ͡£Ñо¿±íÃ÷µ¥Ò»µÄÕë´Ì·½·¨ÁÆÐ§ÓÐÏÞ£¬¶øÁÙ´²ÉÏÖÎÁÆKOAͨ³£²ÉÓø´ºÏÕë¾ÄÁÆ·¨[7]¡£¸ù¾ÝÑ֤ҽѧÀíÂÛ£¬Ðí¶àÑо¿Ì½¾¿Á˲»Í¬Õë¾ÄÁÆ·¨½áºÏÔÚKOAÖÎÁÆÉϵÄÁÆÐ§£¬ÒÔÆÚÖÆ¶¨³öÖÎÁÆKOAµÄ±ê×¼»¯·½°¸¡£±¾Ñо¿Ì½ÌÖÁË»ðÕëÅäºÏƽºâÕë·½·¨ÔÚKOAÖÎÁÆÉϵÄÁÆÐ§£¬ºÍ³£¹æºÁÕë·½·¨Ïà±È£¬»ðÕëÅäºÏƽºâÕëÁÆ·¨ÔÚ»º½â»¼ÕßÌÛÍ´£¬¸ÄÉÆ»¼ÕßÐж¯ÄÜÁ¦ºÍÌá¸ßÖÎÓúºÍÓúÏÔÂÊÉϸüÓÅ¡£
¡¡¡¡1¡¢ ¶ÔÏóºÍ·½·¨
¡¡¡¡1.1¡¢ ¶ÔÏó
¡¡¡¡Ñ¡È¡2016Äê6ÔÂÖÁ2017Äê8ÔÂÔÚ¹ãÖÝÖÐÒ½Ò©´óѧµÚÈý¸½ÊôÒ½Ôº½ÓÊÜKOAÖÎÁƵϼÕß67Àý£¬ÆäÖÐÄÐ28Àý£¬Å®39Àý£¬ÄêÁä41¡«78(57.1±8.4£©Ëê¡£°´ÕÕËæ»úÊý×Ö±í·¨½«»¼Õ߷ֳɵ¥Ò»×飨34Àý£©ºÍ¸´ºÏ×飨33Àý£©£¬µ¥Ò»×é²ÉÓ󣹿ºÁÕëÖÎÁÆ£¬¸´ºÏ×é²ÉÓûðÕëÅäºÏƽºâÕëÖÎÁÆ¡£2×黼ÕßÐԱ𹹳ɡ¢ÄêÁä¡¢²¡³Ì²îÒì¾ùÎÞͳ¼ÆÑ§ÒâÒ壨P>0.05£©£¬¼û±í1¡£±¾Ñо¿¾±¾ÔºÂ×ÀíίԱ»áÅú×¼£¬ËùÓл¼Õß¾ùÇ©ÊðÖªÇéͬÒâÊé¡£
¡¡¡¡1.2 ¡¢ÈëÑ¡±ê×¼
¡¡¡¡KOAÕï¶Ï±ê×¼×ñÑÖлªÒ½Ñ§»á¹Ç¿Æ
¡¡¡¡±í1 2×éKOA»¼ÕßÒ»°ã×ÊÁϱȽÏ
¡¡¡¡Ñ§·Ö»áÖÆ¶©µÄ¹ÇÐԹؽÚÑ×µÄÕïÁÆÖ¸ÄÏ£¨2007Äê°æ£©[8]£º(1)½ü1¸öÔÂÄÚ·´¸´Ï¥¹Ø½ÚÌÛÍ´£»(2)XÏ߯¬£¨Õ¾Á¢»ò¸ºÖØÎ»£©Ê¾¹Ø½Ú¼ä϶±äÕ¡¢Èí¹ÇϹÇÓ²»¯ºÍ£¨»ò£©ÄÒÐԱ䡢¹Ø½ÚÔµ¹Ç׸Ðγɣ»(3)¹Ø½ÚÒº£¨ÖÁÉÙ2´Î£©ÇåÁÁ¡¢ð¤³í£¬°×ϸ°û¼ÆÊý<2 000¸ö/mL;(4)ÄêÁä≥40Ëꣻ(5)³¿½©≤3 min;(6)»î¶¯Ê±ÓйÇĦ²ÁÒô£¨¸Ð£©¡£×ÛºÏÁÙ´²¡¢ÊµÑéÊÒ¼°XÏß¼ì²é£¬·ûºÏÒÔÉÏ(1)¡¢(2)Ìõ»ò(1)¡¢(3)¡¢(5)¡¢(6)Ìõ»ò(1)¡¢(4)¡¢(5)¡¢(6)Ìõ¿ÉÕï¶ÏΪKOA¡£ÄÉÈë±ê×¼£º(1)·ûºÏKOAµÄÕï¶Ï±ê×¼£»(2)»¼ÕßÏ¥¹Ø½ÚÌÛÍ´¡¢Ö×ÕÍ¡¢»î¶¯ÊÜÏÞ£»(3)²¡³Ì≥30 dÇÒδʹÓü¤ËØ¡¢ÃâÒßÒÖÖÆ¼Á¡¢¿¹Ñ×Ö¢ÕòÍ´Ò©µÈ£»(4)»¼ÕßÊìÖªÊÖÊõÊÂÏǩÊðÖªÇéͬÒâÊ飻(5)ÎÞÃ÷ÏÔÐÄ¡¢¸Î¡¢Éö¡¢·Î¹¦Äܲ»È«Õß¡£Åųý±ê×¼£º(1)¹Ø½Ú¼ä¹ÇÇÅÁ¬½Ó¶øµ¼ÖµÄǿֱÐÔ¹ÇÖÊÔöÉúÕߣ¬»ò¹Ø½ÚÑÏÖØ»ûÐΣ¬»¼ÕßÎÞ·¨Õý³£Ðж¯£»(2)ÑÏÖØ¹¦ÄÜÕϰ²¢ÓÐÊÖÊõÖ¸Õ÷Õߣ»(3)Éæ¼°Ï¥¹Ø½ÚµÄÃâÒßϵͳ¼²²¡»¼Õߣ¬ÈçÀà·çʪ¹Ø½ÚÑ×»¼Õߣ»(4)ÓÉÆäËû¼²²¡ÒýÆðµÄÏ¥¹Ø½Ú²¢·¢Ö¢£»(5)ÑÏÖØÆ÷¹Ù²¡±ä¶øÎÞ·¨½øÐÐÁÙ´²Ñо¿Õߣ¬ÈçÐÄÄÔѪ¹Ü¼²²¡»¼Õߣ»(6)ÌØÊ⻼Õߣ¬Èç´¦ÓÚÔÐÆÚºÍ²¸ÈéÆÚµÄ¸¾Å®£¬ÔÎÕëÕߵȣ»(7)ÓÉÓÚ¸÷ÖÖÔÒòδ°´¹æ¶¨½ÓÊÜÖÎÁÆ»òÖÕÖ¹ÖÎÁÆÕß¡£
¡¡¡¡1.3¡¢ ·½·¨
¡¡¡¡1.3.1¡¢ ÖÎÁÆ·½·¨£º
¡¡¡¡È¡º×¶¥¡¢ÁºÇð¡¢ÄÚÏ¥ÑÛ¡¢ÍâÏ¥ÑÛ¡¢Ñªº£¡¢×ãÈýÀïΪÕë¾ÄÖÎÁƵÄÖ÷Ѩ¡£¸ù¾Ý»¼ÕߵľßÌåÇé¿öѡȡ²»Í¬µÄÅäѨ£ºÈçÏ¥¹Ø½ÚÖ×ÕÍ»¼ÕßÅäѨΪÈýÒõѨ¡¢ÒõÁêȪ£»Ï¥ËáÈíÑ¡·üÍá¢ÑôÁêȪΪÅäѨ¡£ÖÎÁÆÖл¼Õß²ÉÓÃÑöÎÔ×ËÊÆ¡£Ã¿¸ô1 d½ÓÊÜ1´ÎÖÎÁÆ£¬ÁƳÌÑÓÐø4¸öÐÇÆÚ[9,10]¡£
¡¡¡¡µ¥Ò»×é²ÉÓúÁÕëÖÎÁÆ£¬°´³£¹æ²Ù×÷¶Ô»¼Õß½øÐÐÖÎÁÆ£¬½øÕëµÃÆøºó²ÉÓÃÆ½²¹Æ½Ðº·¨£¬ÁôÕë30 min[11]¡£¸´ºÏ×é²ÉÓûðÕëÅäºÏƽºâÕëÖÎÁÆ¡£»ðÕëÖÎÁÆ£ºÖ÷ѨÖÐ3¸öÌÛÍ´¸Ð×îÇ¿µÄѨλΪ»ðÕëÖÎÁƵİÐλµã¡£ÖдֻðÕëÉÕºìºó¶ÔÑ¡¶¨µÄѨλ½øÐм²½ø¼²³ö£¬²»ÐèÁôÕë¡£°ÎÕëºóÓÃÏû¶¾¸ÉÃÞÇò°´Ñ¹Õë´Ì²¿Î»[12]¡£Æ½ºâÕëÖÎÁÆ£º»ðÕëÆðÕëºóÐÐÆ½ºâÕëÕë´ÌϥʹѨ¡£°´³£¹æ·½·¨¶ÔѨλ½øÐÐÏû¶¾¡£È¡ÖдֺÁÕë¿ìËÙ½øÕëºóÐÐÌá²åÊÖ·¨£¬È»ºóÐÐÇ¿»¯Õë¸ÐÊÖ·¨£¬ÁôÕë30 minºóÄæÊ±ÕëÄíת³öÕë[13]¡£
¡¡¡¡1.3.2¡¢ ¹Û²ìÖ¸±ê£º
¡¡¡¡²ÉÓÃÊÓ¾õÄ£Äâ²âÊÔ±í£¨visualanalogue scale,VAS£©¶Ô»¼ÕßKOAµÄÑÏÖØ³Ì¶È½øÐÐ×ÜÌåÆÀ¼Û[14]¡£0·Ö±íʾûÓÐÀ§ÄÑ£¬10·Ö±íʾ¼«ÆäÀ§ÄÑ¡£
¡¡¡¡ËùÓл¼ÕßÖÎÁÆÇ°ºó¾ù²ÉÓùǹؽÚÑ×Ö¸ÊýÁ¿±í(western ontario mcmaster universities os-teoarthritis index,WOMAC£©À´ÆÀ¹À[14]¡£WOMAC°üÀ¨ÌÛÍ´¡¢½©Ó²ºÍÈÕ³£»î¶¯¹Ø½ÚÄѶÈÈý¸ö´óÀ࣬×ܹ²24¸öСÀࡣÿ¸öСÀà²ÉÓÃ0¡«10½øÐÐÆÀ·Ö¡£0·Ö±íʾÎÞÖ¢×´£¬10·Ö±íʾ²¡Çé×îÖØ¡£
¡¡¡¡1.3.3¡¢ÁÆÐ§ÆÀ¶¨·½·¨£º
¡¡¡¡°´ÕÕÄáĪµØÆ½·¨À´ÆÀ¹ÀÕë¾Ä·½·¨µÄÁÙ´²ÁÆÐ§[15]¡£¼ÆË㹫ʽΪ£º
¡¡¡¡¸ÄÉÆÂÊ·ÖÖµµÄ¸ßµÍºÍÁÆÐ§Ö®¼äµÄ¹ØÏµÎª£ºÎÞЧ£¨<30%£©£¬ÓÐЧ£¨30%¡«49%£©£¬ÏÔЧ£¨50%¡«75%£©£¬ÖÎÓú£¨>75%£©¡£
¡¡¡¡1.4¡¢ ͳ¼ÆÑ§´¦Àí·½·¨
¡¡¡¡²ÉÓÃSPSS20.0ͳ¼ÆÈí¼þ¶ÔÊý¾Ý½øÐзÖÎö¡£¼ÆÁ¿×ÊÁÏÒÔ±íʾ£¬×éÄÚÖÎÁÆÇ°ºó±È½Ï²ÉÓÃÅä¶Ôt¼ìÑ飬2×é¼ä±È½Ï²ÉÓöÀÁ¢Ñù±¾t¼ìÑ飬¼ÆÊý×ÊÁÏÓÃÀýÊýºÍ°Ù·Ö±È±íʾ£¬×é¼ä±È½Ï²ÉÓÃχ2¼ìÑé¡£P<0.05Ϊ²îÒìÓÐͳ¼ÆÑ§ÒâÒå¡£
¡¡¡¡2¡¢ ½á¹û
¡¡¡¡2.1¡¢ 2×黼ÕßVASÆÀ·Ö±È½Ï
¡¡¡¡2×黼ÕßÖÎÁÆÇ°VASÆÀ·Ö²îÒìÎÞͳ¼ÆÑ§ÒâÒ壨P=0.085£©¡£ÖÎÁƺ󣬵¥Ò»×éºÍ¸´ºÏ×éVASÆÀ·Ö¾ù½ÏÖÎÁÆÇ°ÏÔ׎µµÍ£¨P=0.007,0.008£©¡£¸´ºÏ×éÖÎÁƺóµÄVASÆÀ·ÖÏÔ×ŵÍÓÚµ¥Ò»×飨P=0.023£©£¬¼û±í2¡£
¡¡¡¡2.2 ¡¢2×黼ÕßWOMACÆÀ·Ö±È½Ï
¡¡¡¡µ¥Ò»ºÍ¸´ºÏ×黼ÕßÔÚÖÎÁÆÇ°WOMACÆÀ·Ö²îÒìÎÞͳ¼ÆÑ§ÒâÒ壨P>0.05£©£»ÖÎÁƺó£¬2×黼ÕßWOMACµÄ3¸ö·ÖÀàÆÀ·Ö£¨ÌÛÍ´¡¢½©Ö±ºÍÈÕ³£»î¶¯ÄÜÁ¦£©¼°×Ü·Ö¾ù±È¸÷×ÔÖÎÁÆÇ°ÓÐÃ÷ÏÔ¸ÄÉÆ£¨P<0.05£©¡£2×黼ÕßÖÎÁƺóWOMACÆÀ·Ö±È½ÏÏÔʾ£¬¸´ºÏ×éWOMACÆÀ·ÖµÍÓÚµ¥Ò»×飨P<0.05£©£¬¸´ºÏ×黼ÕßÖ¢×´¸ÄÉÆÓÅÓÚµ¥Ò»×é¡£¼û±í3¡£
¡¡¡¡±í2 2×黼ÕßVASÆÀ·Ö±È½Ï
¡¡¡¡2.3 ¡¢2×黼ÕßÁÙ´²×ÛºÏÁÆÐ§±È½Ï
¡¡¡¡µ¥Ò»×éºÍ¸´ºÏ×黼ÕßKOAÖÎÁƵÄ×ÜÓÐЧÂʲîÒìÎÞͳ¼ÆÑ§ÒâÒ壨P=0.471£©£¬µ«¸´ºÏ×éÔÚÖÎÓúÂÊ£¨χ2=6.452,P=0.021£©ºÍÓúÏÔÂÊ£¨χ2=4.536,P=0.027£©ÉϵÄÁÙ´²ÁÆÐ§Ã÷ÏÔ¸ßÓÚµ¥Ò»×飨¼û±í4£©¡£
¡¡¡¡3¡¢ ÌÖÂÛ
¡¡¡¡KOAÊÇÓÉÓڹؽÚÈí¹Ç»û±ä¶øÒý·¢µÄ¼²²¡[15]¡£ÔÚÖÐÒ½ÉÏ£¬KOAÆðÒòÓÚÌåÐé¡¢ÆøÐ顢ӪѪ²»×ã¡¢ÀÍËðµÈ£¬ÊôÓÚ“¹Ç±Ô”µÄ·¶³ë¡£ÆäµäÐ͵ÄÁÙ´²Ö¢×´°üÀ¨ÌÛÍ´¡¢½©Ó²¡¢»î¶¯Ê±¹Ø½ÚÒ¡°Ú£¬²¢°éËæ×ŹÇ÷ÀÏìÉù[16]¡£ÁÙ´²Éϳ£ÓÃÒ©Îï°üÀ¨ÕòÍ´ÏûÑ×Ò©ÎïºÍÈí¹Ç±£»¤¼Á¡£ËäÈ»ÕâЩҩÎïÔÚijÖ̶ֳÈÉÏÄÜ»º½â²¡Ç飬µ«Ð§¹û²»ÉõÀíÏë¡£²¢ÇÒ³¤ÆÚʹÓÃÕâЩҩÎォµ¼Ö»¼ÕߺóÆÚ³öÏֹؽڻýÒºÔö¶à£¬»¬Ä¤ÔöºñµÈÖ¢×´[17]¡£Òò´ËÎ÷Ò©ÔÚÖÎÁÆKOAÉϵÄ×÷ÓÃÓÐÏÞ¡£ÖÐÒ½Õë¾ÄÁÆ·¨ÓÐ×ÅÓÆ¾ÃµÄÀúÊ·¡£½üÄêÀ´£¬¸÷ÖÖÕë¾ÄÁÆ·¨ÔÚÁÙ´²ÉÏÓÃÒÔÖÎÁÆKOA£¬²¢È¡µÃÁËÁ¼ºÃµÄЧ¹û[18,19]¡£±¾Ñо¿Öг£¹æºÁÕë·¨ÔÚÖÎÁÆKOAʱÏÔ×ŵػº½âÁËKOAµÄÑÏÖØ³Ì¶È£¬¼õÇáÁË»¼ÕßµÄÌÛÍ´¸Ð£¬È¡µÃÁË85.2%µÄÖÎÁÆ×ÜÓÐЧÂÊ£¬ÔÙ´Î˵Ã÷ÁËÕë´ÌÁÆ·¨ÔÚKOAÖÎÁÆÉϵÄÓÐЧÐÔ¡£
¡¡¡¡KOAÊÇÒ»ÖÖ¸´ÔÓµÄÂýÐÔ¼²²¡£¬Óб¨µÀÏÔʾ¸´ºÏÕë¾ÄÁÆ·¨ÔÚ×ÜÁÆÐ§ÐÔÉÏÃ÷ÏÔÓÅÓÚµ¥Ò»Õë´ÌÁÆ·¨[20,21]¡£±¾Ñо¿Ñ¡ÓÃÁË»ðÕëÁÆ·¨¸¨ÖúƽºâÕëÁÆ·¨À´ÖÎÁÆKOA£¬Ïà±ÈÓÚ³£¹æºÁÕëÁÆ·¨£¬»ðÕëÁÆ·¨½«ÕëºÍÈȺ϶þΪһ£¬Í¨¹ýÕëÈÈË«ÖØ´Ì¼¤£¬Æðµ½»º½âÌÛÍ´£¬Ïû³ýÖ×Õ͵ÄЧ¹û¡£ÀîÑÞÃ÷µÈ[22]·¢ÏÖ»ðÕëµÄÈȶȿÉÒÔµ¼ÖÂÕëÌå²åÈëµÄ²¡Àí×éÖ¯ÖÜΧ²¿Î»³öÏÖׯÉË»µËÀ£¬´Ó¶ø¼¤·¢»úÌå×ÔÉíÃâÒߺÍÐÞ¸´ÏµÍ³£¬¶Ô»µËÀ×éÖ¯½øÐÐÍÌÊɺÍÎüÊÕ¡£ËûÃÇ»¹·¢ÏÖ»ðÕë¿ÉÒÔÏÔ׿õÇáKOAÖ¢×´¡¢¸ÄÉÆ¹Ø½Ú΢»·¾³£¬²¢ÇÒ»ðÕëµÄ²Ù×÷¹ý³ÌºÄʱ½ÏÆäËûÕë´ÌÁÆ·¨¶Ì£¬Õ⼫ÊʺÏÏÖ´ú¿ì½Ú×àµÄÉú»î·½Ê½¡£¶ø¸´ºÏÁÆ·¨ÖÐµÄÆ½ºâÕë¾ÄÊÇ´«Í³Ò½Ñ§£¨ÐÄÉñ¿ØÖÆÑ§Ëµ£©ºÍÏÖ´ú¿ÆÑ§ÀíÂÛ£¨ÖÐÊàµ÷¿ØÑ§Ëµ£©Ïà½áºÏ¶ø·¢Õ¹µÄÒ»ÖÖÕë¾Ä·¨[23]¡£Æ½ºâÕë¾ÄµÄÀíÂÛºËÐÄÊÇ»úÌå×ÔÉíÆ½ºâ¡£ÍõÎÄÔ¶½ÌÊÚ[24]ÔøÕë¶ÔƽºâÕë¾ÄѧÌá³ö“Èý°Ðѧ˵”£¬ËûÈÏΪ´óÄÔÊǰÐÖᣬÍâÖÜÉñ¾Êǰе㣬¶ø²¡±ä²¿Î»ÊǰÐλ¡£Æ½ºâÕëÁÆ·¨Ôòͨ¹ý´Ì¼¤°Ðµã²úÉúÐË·Ü£¬ÔÙ½«ÐË·Ü´«µÝ¸ø´óÄÔ£¬´óÄÔÖÐÊà¶ÔËù½ÓÊܵ½µÄÉñ¾³å¶¯×ö³öÏàÓ¦µÄµ÷¿ØÓ¦´ð£¬²¢½«Ö¸Áî´«Ë͵½°Ðλ¡£ÔÚKOAµÄÖÎÁÆÖУ¬Æ½ºâÕëÁÆ·¨Í¨¹ýÕë´Ì´Ì¼¤Ï¥¹Ø½ÚÖÜΧµÄÍâÖÜÉñ¾£¨°Ðµã£©£¬½«Ï¥¹Ø½ÚÎÉÂÒµÄÐÅϢͨ¹ýÉñ¾³å¶¯µÄ·½Ê½´«Èë´óÄÔÖÐÊࣨ°ÐÖᣩ£¬ÖÐÊàÉñ¾ÏµÍ³¶ÔKOAµÄÎÉÂÒÇé¿ö×ö³öÓ¦´ð£¬¼¤»î×ÔÉíµÄÃâÒߺÍÐÞ¸´ÏµÍ³£¬²¢½«Ö¸Áî´«µÝ»ØÏ¥¹Ç¹Ø½Ú£¨°Ð룩¡£Òò´Ë£¬Æ½ºâÕë²¢²»ÊǶÔÏ¥¹Ç¹Ø½ÚµÄÒì³£×ö³öÖ±½ÓÖÎÁÆ£¬¶øÊÇͨ¹ý´Ù½ø»úÌå×ÔÉíµÄÐÞ¸´¡¢µ÷¿ØºÍƽºâÌåϵÀ´Î¢µ÷Ï¥¹Ç¹Ø½ÚµÄÄÚ»·¾³£¬´Ó¶ø´ïµ½ÖÎÁƵÄÄ¿µÄ¡£
¡¡¡¡±í3 2×黼ÕßÖÎÁÆÇ°ºó¼°×é¼äWOMACÆÀ·Ö±È½Ï
¡¡¡¡Óëͬ×éÖÎÁÆÇ°±È£ºaP<0.05
¡¡¡¡±í4 2×黼Õß×ÛºÏÁÆÐ§±È½Ï
¡¡¡¡Óëµ¥Ò»×é±È£ºaP<0.05
¡¡¡¡»ðÕ븨×ôÒÔÆ½ºâÕëÁÆ·¨µÄ×÷ÓûúÖÆÍÆ²âΪÕâÖÖ¸´ºÏ·½·¨¼¤·¢Á˸ü¶àµÄ»úÌåϵͳ²ÎÓëµ÷¿ØÏ¥¹Ç¹Ø½Ú΢»·¾³£¬¸ÄÉÆ¹Ø½ÚµÄѪҺѻ·£¬½µµÍ¹Ø½ÚµÄÑ×Ö¢·´Ó¦¡£±¾Ñо¿ÏÔʾ¸´ºÏÁÆ·¨ÔÚKOAÖÎÓúÂʺÍÓúÏÔÂÊÉÏÏÔןßÓÚµ¥Ò»ºÁÕëÁÆ·¨£¬ÔÚVASºÍWOMACÆÀ·ÖÉÏÏÔ×ŵÍÓÚºÁÕëÁÆ·¨£¬µ«Æä¾ßÌå×÷ÓûúÖÆÈÔ²»ÇåÎú¡£ÓÐÑо¿±íÃ÷KOAµÄÑÏÖØ³Ì¶ÈÓë¾Ö²¿Ï¸°ûÒò×Óº¬Á¿ÓйØ[25]¡£²¢ÇÒ£¬ËðÉËÐÔϸ°ûÒò×Ӻͱ£»¤ÐÔϸ°ûÒò×ÓÖ®¼äµÄÏà¶Ô±ÈÀýÊÇÓ°ÏìKOA³Ì¶ÈµÄÒ»¸öÖØÒªÒòËØ[26]¡£¾¡¹Ü±¾Ñо¿Ã»ÓÐ̽ÌÖ²»Í¬Õë¾Ä·½·¨ÔÚµ÷½âϸ°ûÒò×Ó±í´ïÉϵÄ×÷Ó㬵«¸´ºÏÕë¾Ä·¨ÔÚÖÎÓúÂʺÍÓúÏÔÂÊÉϸßÓÚºÁÕë·¨±íÃ÷µ÷¿ØÏ¸°ûÒò×Ó±í´ïºÜÓпÉÄÜÊǸ´ºÏÕë¾Ä·¨×÷ÓõĻúÖÆÖ®Ò»¡£Ëæ×ÅÏÖ´úÉúÎïѧµÄ·¢Õ¹£¬Í¨¹ý´úл×éѧ¡¢µ°°××éѧºÍ»ùÒò±í´ïÑо¿µÈ·½·¨Ì½Ë÷²»Í¬Õë¾ÄÖÎÁÆÏÂKOA²¿Î»µ°°×ÖʺͻùÒò±í´ïˮƽµÄ¸Ä±ä½«ÓÐÖúÓÚ¾«×¼ÕÒ³öÖÎÁưе㡣Õ⽫ÊǽñºóÖÎÁÆKOAµÄÑо¿ÖصãËùÔÚ¡£ÁíÍ⣬´ËÑо¿Ñù±¾Á¿½ÏС£¬¶ÔÓÚ»¼ÕߵĻù´¡×ÊÁÏÊÕ¼¯ÉÏ»¹Óдý¸Ä½ø£¬ÀýÈ综ÕßµÄKOAÊÇÔ·¢»¹ÊǼ̷¢µÈ¡£
¡¡¡¡±¾Ñо¿±íÃ÷»ðÕë½áºÏƽºâÕë·¨ÔÚ¸ÄÉÆ»¼ÕßÁÙ´²Ö¢×´£¬»Ö¸´Ï¥¹Ç¹Ø½Ú¹¦ÄÜ£¬¼õÇáÑ×Ö¢·´Ó¦ÉϾùÓÅÓÚ³£¹æºÁÕë·¨¡£Ëæ×ÅÖÐÒ½ÁÙ´²ºÍÎ÷ҽʵÑéÑо¿µÄ²»¶ÏÉîÈëºÍ½áºÏ£¬ÏàÐÅÕë¾Ä·½·¨ÔÚKOAÉϵÄÖÎÁÆÔÚ²»¾ÃµÄ½«À´»áÓÐÒ»¸öÖʵÄÍ»ÆÆ¡£
¡¡¡¡²Î¿¼ÎÄÏ×
¡¡¡¡[1] WOOD L R, PEAT G, THOMAS E, et al. Knee osteoarthritis in community-dwelling older adults:are there characteristic patterns of pain location?[J]. Osteoarthritis Cartilage,2007, 15(6):615-623.
¡¡¡¡[2] Ëï¾§,²ÌÉܽÜ,»ÆÎ°.Õë¾ÄÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹ÇÐԹؽÚÑ×µÄÖη¨×ÛÊö[J].ºþ±±ÖÐÒ½Ò©´óѧѧ±¨, 2017, 19(4):120-125.
¡¡¡¡[3] ÕÔ¾ê,ÍõÊ¢´º.Õë¾ÄÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹ÇÐԹؽÚÑ×ÁÙ´²Ñо¿½ü¿ö[J].ɽ¶«ÖÐÒ½Ò©´óѧѧ±¨, 2015, 39(6):578-580.
¡¡¡¡[4] ÌÆ²¼Ãô,Ö£ÏþÑà,ÍòÇÉÇÙ,µÈ.Ï¥¹Ø½Ú¹ÇÐԹؽÚÑ×»¼ÕßÉú»îÖÊÁ¿¼°¸ÉÔ¤Ñо¿ÏÖ×´[J].ÏÖ´úÔ¤·Àҽѧ, 2016, 43(1):121-123.
¡¡¡¡[5] ºî½¨Åô,ÁõÅô,½ªÊ¤·å,µÈ.ÕëÒ©½áºÏÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹Ø½Ú¹ÇÐԹؽÚÑ×µÄÁÙ´²Ñо¿½øÕ¹[J].Õë¾ÄÁÙ´²ÔÓÖ¾, 2016, 32(11):98-102.
¡¡¡¡[6] °¬½ðΰ,ÀîµÂʤ,ÁõÓð,µÈ.ÖÐÒ½±çÖ¤ÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹ÇÐԹؽÚÑ×µÄÍø×´Meta·ÖÎö[J].ÖйúÑ֤ҽѧÔÓÖ¾, 2016, 16(5):532-542.
¡¡¡¡[7] LEE H. Evidence is insufficient to support fire-needle moxibustion in patients with knee osteoarthritis[J]. Focus Altern Complement Ther, 2016, 21(3-4):150-151.
¡¡¡¡[8] ÖлªÒ½Ñ§»á¹Ç¿ÆÑ§·Ö»á.¹Ç¹Ø½ÚÑ×ÕïÖÎÖ¸ÄÏ(2007Äê°æ)[J].Öлª¹Ç¿ÆÔÓÖ¾, 2007, 27(10):793-796.
¡¡¡¡[9] ÀîÓÀæÃ,ʯ¹ãϼ,ÍÀ½¨·æ,µÈ.Õë¾ÄÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹Ç¹Ø½ÚÑ×ѡѨ¹æÂÉ·ÖÎö[J].ÁÉÄþÖÐÒ½ÔÓÖ¾, 2017, 44(10):2179-2182.
¡¡¡¡[10] ÁøÇà,µÔΰ,ÈÎÇïÀ¼,µÈ.Ï¥¹Ç¹Ø½ÚÑ×Õë¾ÄȡѨÅäÎ鹿ÂÉdzÎö[J].ÁÉÄþÖÐÒ½ÔÓÖ¾, 2015, 42(5):927-929.
¡¡¡¡[11] ÔªÓÀ½ð,ÕÔÒ«¶«,ÕŹúÏþ,µÈ.»ùÓÚ¾½îÀíÂÛ̽ÌÖºÁÕë´Ì·¨ÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹ÇÐԹؽÚÑ×[J].ÖлªÖÐÒ½Ò©ÔÓÖ¾, 2018, 33(3):979-982.
¡¡¡¡[12] ÕÅ־ǿ,°×ΰ½Ü,Ö£ÀûȺ.ÁõÊϺÁ»ðÕëÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹Ø½Ú¹ÇÐԹؽÚÑ×µÄÁÙ´²Ñо¿[J].Õë¾ÄÁÙ´²ÔÓÖ¾, 2017, 33(5):52-54.
¡¡¡¡[13] ËïÄþ,ÀîÓÀæÃ,ÁÖè´è´,µÈ.²»Í¬Õë¾ÄÁÆ·¨ÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹Ç¹Ø½ÚÑ׵ıȽÏÓë·ÖÎö[J].ÖлªÖÐÒ½Ò©ÔÓÖ¾, 2017, 32(7):3253-3255.
¡¡¡¡[14] ºØÐ¡»Ü,ÕÅÉÙÃ÷.²»Í¬Õë¾Ä·½Ê½¶ÔÐ麮ÐÍÏ¥¹Ç¹Ø½ÚÑ×»¼ÕßWOMACÆÀ·Ö¼°ÌÛÍ´Ö¢×´µÄÓ°Ïì±È½Ï[J].ÉÂÎ÷ÖÐÒ½, 2017,38(4):511-512.
¡¡¡¡[15] ºÎºé²¨,ÕŽÜ.Õë¾ÄÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹Ç¹Ø½ÚÑ×ÁÆÐ§ÆÀ¼Û·½·¨¸Å¿ö[J].ÁÉÄþÖÐÒ½Ò©´óѧѧ±¨, 2017, 19(7):147-150.
¡¡¡¡[16] XIE D Y, JIANG Y X, CHEN R X, et al. Study on the thermesthesia features of heat-sensitive acupoints in patients with knee osteoarthritis[J]. J Acupunct Tuina Sci, 2016,14(2):110-114.
¡¡¡¡[17] ¸ßÖ¾.Ï¥¹Ø½Ú¹Ç¹Ø½ÚÑ×¾ÖÐÎ÷Ò½²»Í¬ÁÆ·¨µÄ¶Ô±ÈÑо¿[J].ÊÀ½çÖÐÒ½Ò©, 2017, 12(8):1767-1770
¡¡¡¡[18] ÕűØÃÈ,ÎâÒ«³Ö,Éò½¡.³¤Õë͸´ÌÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹Ç¹Ø½ÚÑ×µÄÁÙ´²Ñо¿[J].ÖйúÕë¾Ä, 2004, 24(9):613-614.
¡¡¡¡[19] ÕÅÓÀ³¼,¬³Ð¶¥.çÑ´Ì·¨ÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹ÇÐԹؽÚÑ×54Àý[J].Õë¾ÄÁÙ´²ÔÓÖ¾, 2012, 28(6):20-21.
¡¡¡¡[20] ·üÐãϼ.¶Ì´ÌÎÂÕë¾ÄÅäºÏ´ÌÂç°Î¹ÞÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹Ç¹Ø½ÚÑ×ÁÆÐ§¹Û²ì[J].ÉϺ£Õë¾ÄÔÓÖ¾, 2011, 30(8):564-565.
¡¡¡¡[21] Àîǧ.ÎÂÕë¾Ä¼ÓÖÐÒ©ÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹Ç¹Ø½ÚÑ×80ÀýÁÆÐ§¹Û²ì[J].ÉîÛÚÖÐÎ÷Ò½½áºÏÔÓÖ¾, 2015, 25(1):73-74.
¡¡¡¡[22] ÀîÑÞÃ÷,Ô¬Áâ÷,³ÂÀöÃÃ.ÎÂÕë¾ÄÅäºÏ»ðÕëÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹ÇÐԹؽÚÑ×36Àý[J].Õë¾ÄÁÙ´²ÔÓÖ¾, 2015, 31(7):54-56.
¡¡¡¡[23] Ò¶Ó¾ËÉ,Áõ²¨,³ÂÖ¾¹â.¾²Ï¢Ì¬ÄÔ¹¦Äܼ¼Êõ¶ÔƽºâÕëÖÎÁÆÖÐÊà»úÖÆµÄ·ÖÎöÓ¦ÓÃ[J].Öйú×éÖ¯¹¤³ÌÑо¿ÓëÁÙ´²¿µ¸´,2011, 15(48):8998-9002.
¡¡¡¡[24] ÍõÎÄÔ¶.ÍõÊÏÆ½ºâÕëÁÆ·¨[M].±±¾©:ÖйúÖÐÒ½Ò©³ö°æÉç,2016:78-86.
¡¡¡¡[25] ö¤è´,ÍõÓñ,Öܾ§±ù,µÈ.ÄÚÈÈÕëÁªºÏÔÆ¿ËÁÆ·¨ÖÎÁÆÏ¥¹Ø½Ú¹ÇÐԹؽÚÑ×µÄÁÆÐ§¼°Æä¶Ô»¼ÕßIL-1ºÍTNF-αˮƽµÄÓ°Ïì[J].ÊÀ½çÖÐÒ½Ò©, 2017, 12(12):3124-3127.
¡¡¡¡[26] ³ÂÒæµ¤,Çñ»ªÆ½,½ðФÇà,µÈ.²»Í¬Õë¾Ä·½·¨¶ÔÏ¥¹Ç¹Ø½ÚÑ×Ä£ÐÍϸ°ûÒò×Ó¼°»ùÖʽðÊôµ°°×øӰÏìµÄ±È½ÏÑо¿[J].Öйú±È½ÏҽѧÔÓÖ¾, 2016, 26(1):42-45, 64.