参考文献:
[1] 百度百科。大数据时代[EB/OL]. [2014-03-28].
[2] 维克托?迈尔-舍恩伯格。删除 M.袁杰,译。浙江:浙江人民出版社,2013.1.
[3] VIKTOR MAYER-SCH?NBERGER. DELETE: THE VIRTUE OF FORGETTING IN THE DIGITAL AGE.Princeton:Princeton University Press,2009
[4] Artemi Rallo Lombarte. El derecho al olvido y su protección. A partir de la protección de datos, TELOS: CUADERNOS DE COMUNICACI?N E INNOVACI?N 85, 104–08 (2010)。
[5] Pere Simon Castellano.El régimen constitucional del derecho al olvido en Internet, in NET NEUTRALITY AND OTHER CHALLENGES FOR THE FUTURE OF THE INTERNET 391–406 (Agustí Cerrillo i Martínez, Miguel Peguera, Isabel Pe?a-López, Mónica Vilasau Solana ed., 2011)。
[6] Contribution of the AEPD to the European Commission's consultation hereinafter EC consultation, 2011, available.
[7] Agencia Espa?ola de Protección de Datos hereinafter AEPD Decision procedure no. TD/01335/2008 and no. TD/00627/2009.
[8] AEPD Decision procedure no. TD/00266/2007.
[9] Lorenzo Cotino. Datos personales y libertades informativas. Medios de comunicación social como fuentes accesibles al público (Art. 3 de la LOPD), in COMENTARIO A LA LEY ORG?NICA DE PROTECCI?N DE DATOS PERSONALES 289–315 (Antonio Troncoso Reigada ed., 2010)。
[10] Contribution of the German Federal Government to the EC consultation, 2011, available at . (The German Federal Government has been "very interested in the idea of an 'expiry date for data' but again technical implementation seems to be a great challenge")。
[11] Contribution of the Belgian Data Protection Authority to the EC consultation, 2011, available at. (More specifically, historical and cultural data are protected under freedom of information and for this reason must be transferred to archives dedicated to historical research and "should be encouraged and treated as a valid way to retain data beyond their operational utility date")。
[12] Contribution of the Information Commissioner's Office to the EC consultation, 2011, available .
[13] Peter Hustinx, Towards more effective Data Protection in the Information Society, REVISTA DE LA AGENCIA DE PROTECCI?N DE DATOS DE LA COMUNIDAD DE MADRID 50(2011)。
[14] Council conclusions on the Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council - A comprehensive approach on personal data protection in the European Union, adopted on 3071st Justice and Home Affairs Council meeting, 2011.
[15] Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council - A comprehensive approach on personal data protection in the European Union, 2010.
[16] A Rouvroy, Réinventer l'art d'oublier et de se Faire oublier dans la Société de l' information? Version augmentée (2008) available at .
[17] Ambrose, Meg Leta and Ausloos, Jef, The Right to Be Forgotten Across the Pond (September21, 2012)。 2012 TRPC, Journal of Information Policy, Volume 3 (2013), pg. 1-23. Availableat SSRN.
[18] European Commission, Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on the protection of individuals with regard to the processing of persona l data and on the free movement of such data (General Data Protection Regulation), 25.01.2012, COM(2012) 11 final .
[19] Schwartz.The Computer in German and American Constitutional Law: Towards an American Right of Informational Self-Determination, 37 Am. J. Comp. L. 675, 676, 683 (1989)。
[20] Gerrit Hornung and Christoph . Schnabel.Data protection in Germany I: The population census decision and the right to informational self-determination .Computer Law & Security Report, Volume 25, Issue 1, 2009, Pages 84-88
[21] Rouvroy Antoinet te, Poullet Yves. The right to information self-determination and the value of self-de velopment: reassessing the importance of privacy for democracy. In: Gutwirth Serge, Poullet Yves, de Hert Paul, de Terwangne Cecil, Nout Sjaak, editors. Reinventing data protection? Berlin: Springer; 2009.
[22] Lagone, Laura, The Right to Be Forgotten: A Comparative Analysis (December 7, 2012)。 Available at SSRN.
[23] Simón Castellano, Pere, The Right to Be Forgotten Under European Law: A Constitutional Debate (September 7, 2011)。 Lex Electronica, Vol. 16, no1 (Hiver/Winter 2012)。 Available at SSRN.
[24] Graux, Hans and Ausloos, Jef and Valcke, Peggy, The Right to Be Forgotten in the Internet Era (November 12, 2012)。 ICRI Research Paper No. 11. Available at SSRN.
[25] Walker, Robert Kirk.The Right to be Forgotten (November 20, 2012)。 64 Hastings Law Journal 257, December 2012. Available at SSRN.
[26] Vivian Reding, Speech/12/26, The EU Data Protection Reform 2012: Making Europe the Standard Setter for Modern Data Protection Rules in the Digital Age, (speech before Innovation Conference Digital, Life, Design, Munich, Jan. 22 2012)。
[27] Ausloos, Jef.The 'Right to be Forgotten' – Worth remembering? Computer Law & Security Review, Volume 28, Issue 2, April 2012, Pages 143-152. Available at SSRN.
[28] Andrade, Norberto Nuno Gomes de, Oblivion: The Right to Be Different from Oneself - Reproposing the Right to Be Forgotten (February 1, 2012)。 "VII International Conference on Internet, Law & Politics. Net Neutrality and other challenges for the future of the Internet", IDP. Revista de Internet, Derecho y Política. No. 13, pp. 122-137. UOC. Available at SSRN.
[29] Paul A. Bernal, A Right to delete? European Journal of Law and Technology, Vol 2, No 2(2011)
[30] Victor, Jacob M., The EU General Data Protection Regulation: Toward a Property Regime for Protecting Data Privacy (August 1, 2013)。 Yale Law Journal, Forthcoming. Available at SSRN.
[31] Mitrou, Lilian and Karyda, Maria, EU's Data Protection Reform and the Right to be Forgotten: A Legal Response to a Technological Challenge? (February 5, 2012)。 5th International Conference of Information Law and Ethics 2012, Corfu-Greece, June 29-30, 2012. Available at SSRN.
[32] Lagone, Laura, The Right to Be Forgotten: A Comparative Analysis (December 7, 2012)。Available at SSRN.
[33] Simón Castellano, Pere, The Right to Be Forgotten Under European Law: A Constitutional Debate (September 7, 2011)。 Lex Electronica, Vol. 16, n°1 (Hiver/Winter 2012)。 Available at SSRN.
[34] 王汝林。发展"云计算"必须高度重视"云安全"[J].中国信息界,2011,(1):5
[35] 范平。企业数据泄露 内部威胁远大于外部环境。[EB/OL].[2013-11-10].
[36] e.g., The Florida Star v. B.J.F., 491 U.S. 524, 532 (1989) ("If a newspaper lawfully obtains truthful information about a matter of public significance then state officials may not constitutionally punish publication of the information, absent a need to further a state interest of the highest order.")。
[37] U.S. Dept. of Justice v. Reporters Comm. For Freedom of Press, 489 U.S. 749, 769 (1989)。
[38] Private Data, Public Rules, The Economist, Jan. 28, 2012, see also Ashley Messenger, What Would A "Right to Be Forgotten" Mean for Media in the United States?, Comm. Law. 29, 35 (2012)。
[39] Graux, Hans and Ausloos, Jef and Valcke, Peggy. The Right to Be Forgotten in the Internet Era (November 12, 2012)。 ICRI Research Paper No. 11. Available at SSRN.
[40] Simón Castellano, Pere, The Right to Be Forgotten Under European Law: A Constitutional Debate (September 7, 2011)。 Lex Electronica, Vol. 16, n°1 (Hiver/Winter 2012)。 Available at SSRN.
[41] Ambrose, Meg Leta and Ausloos, Jef, The Right to Be Forgotten Across the Pond (September 21, 2012)。 2012 TRPC, Journal of Information Policy, Volume 3 (2013), pg. 1-23. Available at SSRN.
[42] Hoofnagle, Chris Jay and Whittington, Jan, The Price of 'Free': Accounting for the Cost of the Internet's Most Popular Price (March 19, 2013)。 Forthcoming UCLA Law Review, Vol. 61, No. 3, 2014. Available at SSRN.
[43] Mitrou, Lilian and Karyda, Maria, EU's Data Protection Reform and the Right to be Forgotten: A Legal Response to a Technological Challenge? (February 5, 2012)。 5th International Conference of Information Law and Ethics 2012, Corfu-Greece, June 29-30, 2012. Available at SSRN.
[44] European Union, Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, 7 December 2000, Official Journal of the European Communities, 18 December 2000 (2000/C 364/01)。
[45] Private Data, Public Rules, The Economist, Jan. 28, 2012, see also Ashley Messenger, What Would A "Right to Be Forgotten" Mean for Media in the United States?, Comm. Law. 29, 35 (2012)。
[46] Vera Bergelson.It's Personal but Is It Mine? Toward Property Rights in Personal Information , 37 U.C. DAVIS L. R EV. 379, 403 (2003) (describing how U.S. law does not grant individuals property rights in their personal information ); see also NADEZHDA P URTOVA, PROPERTY RIGHTS IN PERSONAL DATA: A EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVE 153 - 92 (2011) (surveying European data protection law and contrasting it with a hypothetical property - based regime)。
[47] Jessica Litman. Information Privacy/Information Property, 52 STAN. L. R EV. 1283, 1284(2000)
[48] e.g., In re Northwest Airlines Privacy Litigation, 2004 WL 1278459 (D. Minn. 2004) (stating that when passengers voluntarily gave Northwest Airlines their personal information and Northwest Airlines compiled that information into a data record, the record "itself became Northwest's property")
[49] Gordley, Foundations of Private Law : Property, Tort, Contract, Unjust Enrichment.
[50] J.W. Bruce, Ely, James W. Jr Cases and Materials on Modern Property Law, 6th ed. (Thomson West)。 P. 19; Remigius N. Nwabueze. Biotechnology and the Challenge of Property, ed. Sheila McLean, Medical Law and Ethics (Aldershot - Burlington: Ashgate, 2007)。 ; Kevin Gray.Property in Thin Air. Cambridge Law Journal 50, no. 2 (1991)。; Roy Vogt.Whose Property? The Deepening Conflict between Private Property and Democracy in Canada (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1999)。 Etc.
[51] Zogby International Poll.
[52] Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on the Protection of Individuals with Regard to the Processing of Personal Data and on the Free Movement of Such Data (25 Jan. 2012) at Art. 4 .
[53] e.g., The Florida Star v. B.J.F., 491 U.S. 524, 532 (1989)
[54] N Purtova, Property Rights in Personal Data: a European Perspective, PhD Thesis, Tilburg University (2011) , at 65 .
[55] Cf BJ Koops, " Law, Technology, and Shifting Power Relations " (2010) 25 Berkeley Technology Law Journal 973 -1035.
[56] 齐爱民。中华人民共和国个人信息保护法示范法草案学者建议稿[J].河北法学,2005,23(6)。
致 谢
光阴似箭,时光荏苒,三年的研究生生涯即将画上句号。在这三年的时光里,我得到了很大的进步,不仅仅是知识水平的提高,更重要的是学习能力的提升和思想观念的成熟。在这里,要感谢所有给与我关心和帮助的人们。
首先,要感谢我的导师肖冬梅老师。肖老师对学生的悉心教导和极高的工作热情让我敬佩,也鼓舞我成长。在本论文历经一年半的完成时间里,肖老师更是为我提供了非常大的帮助。在论文选题、外文参考资料的获取、文章结构的安排和调整、文章的修改和完善方面都给予了我很多的意见和鼓励。
此外,要感谢曾经教导我的老师,在学习道路上给与我的指引。感谢我的父母,对于我学习一如既往的无私支持和付出。感谢我的同学和朋友,在学习和生活过程中的相互探讨和陪伴。
最后,要感谢来参与我此次论文答辩的各位老师,由于我的学术水平有限,本文难免有不足之处,恳请各位老师批评指正。